Obama's NSA speech leaves more questions than answers

US President Barack Obama is seen through a teleprompter as he speaks at the Justice Department in Washington DC on 17 January 2014 President Obama said he was ending bulk data collection in its current form - without spelling out what replaces it

The president opened up his big speech with a justification for spying on the British. Don't worry. It was a reference to the war of independence and Paul Revere.

His whole tone was rather academic; it was one of those sweeping speeches that are more like a long-form magazine article than a normal job of political persuasion.

But it was about persuading people - that he was balanced, judicious and had carefully weighed all the options.

Maybe so, but the conclusion was that he hadn't really reached a conclusion. At least not on what is perhaps the central question.

He said the collection of bulk data must go on; it hadn't been abused but it was understandable why it led to disquiet.

So he was ending it in its current form - without spelling out what replaces it.

He seems to have to rejected one suggestion - that the internet and phone companies should hold on to the data themselves - and has given the attorney general and the NSA 60 days to find a way to square the circle.

Congress will also be involved. "Over to you, Eric", is hardly the most inspiring conclusion to weeks of talking to everyone involved and after an official report making 46 recommendations.

His other main order is to end spying on friendly foreign leaders, unless there is a compelling national security reason. Most of his instructions have similar "get out of jail" cards attached.

Basically there's a lot of stuff he now says the NSA shouldn't do. Unless they think they ought to.

The president has not put a lid on this debate - indeed he rather has given the pot a vigorous stir.

What he's announced shouldn't upset the intelligence community - and is unlikely to greatly reassure civil liberties groups - but both sides will be left with more questions than answers.

Mark Mardell Article written by Mark Mardell Mark Mardell Presenter, The World This Weekend

Is Scottish Labour leader Jim Murphy about to bring back Blairism?

Those on the left think new Scottish Labour leader Jim Murphy could be about to take the party back to the days of Tony Blair, says the BBC's Mark Mardell.

Read full article

More on This Story

Related Stories

Features & Analysis

Elsewhere on the BBC

  • HobbitHobbit review

    Nicholas Barber asks whether The Battle of the Five Armies is worthwhile or unnecessary

Programmes

  • Digital candlesClick Watch

    Inside the 'Harry Potter' church, using technology to explore "digital empathy".

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.