Stars boycott Beverly Hills Hotel over Brunei 'sharia'

 

Regan Morris reports on the reason for the protests

Related Stories

Stars of Hollywood are boycotting one of the area's most famous hotels because of a harsh Islamic penal code introduced by Brunei's government.

Comedians Jay Leno and Ellen DeGeneres are among the celebrities supporting the boycott against the Beverly Hills Hotel and other hotels owned by Brunei.

After a heated debate, the city council unanimously voted to condemn Brunei.

Brunei's leader, Sultan Hassanal Bolkiah, announced the first phase of the new penalties last week.

Analysis

The Beverly Hills Hotel is so ingrained in Hollywood culture that it's hard to imagine it without the stars.

The hotel bar, the Polo Lounge, is one of the best places in town to spot celebrities. The pink hotel opened in 1912 and has a storied history - Elizabeth Taylor lived there as a child and also as an adult with Richard Burton.

Aviator Howard Hughes resided on and off for about 30 years and more recently you could bump into Tom Cruise or Ozzy Osbourne in the lobby.

But now the Motion Picture & Television Fund and the International Women Media Foundation have said they plan to find another venue for their glitzy events. While that will hurt business at the hotel, what remains to be seen is if its celebrity clientele will also take their business elsewhere.

So far, this boycott only involves a handful of celebrities.

They will eventually include death by stoning for homosexuality and adultery.

The mayor of Beverly Hills, Lili Bosse, had urged the city council to adopt a resolution condemning Brunei's new laws and force the country to sell the hotel and others it owns through the Dorchester Collection chain.

The council unanimously passed a resolution condemning the sultanate but the meeting was divided on whether to boycott the hotel. Many disagreed with Mayor Bosse's decision to no longer attend functions there.

Virgin group founder Richard Branson tweeted on Saturday that his employees and family would not stay at the luxury hotel chain "until the Sultan abides by basic human rights".

Several organisations have cancelled events at the hotel, long a gathering place for Hollywood celebrities, including the Motion Picture & Television Fund's annual Night Before the Oscars charity event and the Feminist Majority Foundation's annual Global Women's Rights Awards.

During a small protest in front of the hotel on Monday, Mr Leno said: "I'd like to think that all people are basically good and when they realise this is going on, hopefully they'll do something about it."

But Christopher Cowdray, the chief executive of the Dorchester Collection chain, said those protesting have ignored local hotels owned by countries with poor human rights records.

"There are other hotel companies in this city that are owned by Saudi Arabia... you know, your shirt probably comes from a country which has human rights issues," Mr Cowdray said, adding a boycott would hurt local employees the most.

Jay Leno speaks at a gathering of Women's Rights and LGBT groups protesting across from the Beverly Hills Hotel, 5 May 2014 Jay Leno speaks at the protest across from the Beverly Hills Hotel
The Beverly Hills Hotel, Beverly Hills, California 5 May 2014. The hotel has drawn an elite Hollywood clientele in the past, including the likes of Elizabeth Taylor

Badrul Chowdhury, a waiter who has worked at the hotel for 14 years, told Reuters news agency that events in Brunei were far removed from the lives of hotel workers.

"We work. We take care of our families," he said.

The US government has been largely quiet on the change to Brunei's penal code, but the state department said on Tuesday it had privately relayed concerns to the Brunei government.

Sharia: What it means

  • Islam's legal system, derived from the Koran
  • Informs every aspect of Muslims' lives
  • Islamic jurists issue formal guidance through fatwas, or religious edicts
  • Sharia law includes provisions for capital and corporal punishment but modern scholars say getting to that stage can be difficult
  • Marriage is treated as a contract in Islam

The initial phase of the new penal code introduces fines or prison terms for offences including indecent behaviour, failure to attend Friday prayers and pregnancies out-of-wedlock.

The second phase due to start later this year will cover crimes such as theft and robbery and will involve more stringent penalties such as amputations and flogging.

The most severe punishments, such as death by stoning for offences including sodomy and adultery, will be introduced late next year

Brunei officials have previously said that judges would be given discretion in sentencing. It is not clear to what extent the code will apply to non-Muslims.

The tiny state on the island of Borneo has grown rich on oil and gas exports.

Almost three-quarters of those who live there are Malay Muslims, but there are sizeable Buddhist and Christian communities.

 

More on This Story

Related Stories

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 763.

    The westerners are at it again by going after attacking Islam.Countries that took hundreds of years to be were they are today expect others to automatically be like them in a instant.
    The arrogant west forgets its evolutionary process and like a control freak want to "make"people by force conform to their way of thinking.The Saudi government and others will change by engaging with them.

  • Comment number 762.

    This comment was removed because the moderators found it broke the house rules. Explain.

  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 761.

    759. Sacala
    True in some respects, but in modern democracies, politics is at least based on reasoned debate, consensus and evidence.
    _______

    I disagree. In recent years, in Britain, we have reached an absolute low in terms reasonable debate and consensus, and evidence is out of the window altogether. From that point of view, religious and political leaders are the same peddlers of fiction.

  • rate this
    +1

    Comment number 760.

    The U.S., and for that matter any westernized free country, should ban Islamic investment in properties in those countries, for human rights reasons.

  • rate this
    +2

    Comment number 759.

    757 It_s yerself
    "Religion is no different from political ideologies."

    ---------------------------------------------
    True in some respects, but in modern democracies, politics is at least based on reasoned debate, consensus and evidence.

    With religion however, ideas don't have to make sense, be moral or be based on evidence.

 

Comments 5 of 763

 

More US & Canada stories

RSS

Features & Analysis

Elsewhere on the BBC

Programmes

  • A tankHARDtalk Watch

    The West looks 'really weak' against a 'power drunk' Russia, says a senior Ukrainian diplomat

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.