US & Canada

All-male White House health bill photo sparks anger

Mike Pence and Freedom Caucus Image copyright White House

There is a familiarity about this photo, and it could have been taken in many boardrooms around the world - men gathered around a table making plans and cutting deals.

But the lack of women here, among a group of conservative Republicans discussing their healthcare bill with the vice-president, struck a particular nerve.

That's because one of the points under discussion was whether the new bill should mandate that health insurance plans provide "essential benefits" including maternity services.

In January, the White House came in for some flak when President Trump signed an abortion order surrounded by men.

So the reaction was swift when Vice-President Mike Pence tweeted the photo, with the words: "Appreciated joining @POTUS for meeting with the Freedom Caucus again today This is it. #PassTheBill"

Democratic Senator Patty Murray was one of the first to respond, making an ironic observation.

Image copyright Twitter

The image also dismayed Democratic Congressman Jim McGovern, who described it as an outrage.

Image copyright Twitter

Others gave a numeric illustration to make their point.

Image copyright Twitter

One woman - a Trump adviser, Kellyanne Conway - and 28 men can be seen in another photo of Thursday's meeting, tweeted out by the president's special assistant Cliff Sims.

The president has been keen to include women in the photographs of him signing executive orders, ever since the White House was heavily crticised for an all-male photo of him legislating on abortions, on his first day in the job.

Why are people talking about this photo?

And Dan Scavino, President Trump's social media director, was quick to respond to the criticism on Thursday by tweeting a female-friendly photo of the president and his vice-president negotiating the healthcare bill with a group of moderate Republicans.

Image copyright Cliff Sims
Image caption Another photograph of the meeting shows one woman, Kellyanne Conway, present

Less than a fifth of Republicans in the House of Representatives are women, but gender representation is not just a Republican problem - the US Congress as a whole is still dominated by men.

With 20% female, the US ranks alongside Bangladesh in global terms. In Sweden it's 44%.

Media playback is unsupported on your device
Media captionThe new US congress is most diverse ever - but is it enough?

The US is not the only country to have an all-male photograph from the corridors of power sparking debate.

Last week, an inaugural girls' council in al-Qassim province in Saudi Arabia was condemned when the first pictures showed 13 men on stage, but no women.

Image copyright Twitter

The disquiet over the Mike Pence photo has put the spotlight on the concessions that President Trump is offering to the conservative wing of his party, namely to strip the new health bill of "essential benefits".

Conservatives have long wanted to reverse an Obamacare requirement that all health plans include 10 key benefits, including emergency services, drug use treatment and maternity care.

It has led some people to question why they are paying for services they say they do not need - like pediatric care for people who have no intention of having children.

Image copyright Qassim Girls Council
Image caption There were a total of 13 men (not all pictured) on stage to launch the Qassim Girls Council in Saudi Arabia

Republican Senator Pat Roberts expressed that view on Thursday, when asked about the negotiations, saying: "I wouldn't want to lose my mammograms."

He later tweeted an apology: "I deeply regret my comments on a very important topic. Mammograms are essential to women's health & I never intended to indicate otherwise."


More on the healthcare story

Media playback is unsupported on your device
Media captionWhat's in the Republican healthcare bill?

Related Topics