"To me he's better than ever," said seven-time Grand Slam winner McEnroe.
Nadal has now won all 22 hard-court matches he has played in 2013
He has won 10 titles this year, from 12 finals
He has lost only three of 63 matches all year
He had won 88 consecutive service games until Richard Gasquet broke him in the semi-final
"He's moving better; it was amazing to see how much he wanted it. His will to win... I've never seen anyone like it."
The Spaniard was out for seven months through injury but since coming back in February, he has won 10 titles, including Grand Slams at
and US Opens, and gone unbeaten in 22 hard-court matches.
"It's amazing because he was watching on TV [last year]," McEnroe, a four-time US Open champion, told BBC Radio 5 live.
"We were worried about his career, then he doesn't play Australia, and all of a sudden he comes back. For a while, we're still thinking is he going to be able to come all the way back?
"He wins the French, but that's expected in a way, but he looked like his old self. When he lost first round of Wimbledon, I started worrying again. I thought the knee was bothering him, but he comes back and wins both hard-court events [Montreal and Cincinnati]."
Most Grand Slam singles titles
- Roger Federer
- Pete Sampras
- Rafael Nadal
- Roy Emerson
- Rod Laver, Bjorn Borg
Nadal has moved to within one of Pete Sampras in the all-time list of male Grand Slam singles winners and four behind leader Roger Federer's mark of 17.
"I think if he stays healthy he can easily win four or five more, no doubt about it," said McEnroe.
"Let's hope that he stays healthy because it would be great for our sport - and somebody's going to have to step up!"
Former British number one John Lloyd believes Nadal's recovery from injury and subsequent form makes his year the greatest in the history of tennis for any player.
"Even if Nadal loses a few matches towards the end of the year in some of the Masters series events, it does not matter," he told 5 live.
Rafael Nadal says his second US Open title is his "most emotional win"
"It is one of the greatest years of all time and in my opinion it is probably the greatest year a tennis player has ever had."
Lloyd added: "I feel Roger Federer is going to be caught. As long as Rafa's injuries hold out I think he will break the record."
Former Wimbledon champion Pat Cash agreed that Nadal was now a serious threat to Federer at the top of the Grand Slam standings.
"Nadal could surpass Federer's total of 17," the Australian said.
"That debate over who is the greatest is fun but pointless, but you can't argue with eight French Opens and maybe more to come.
"He has got a style of game that nobody has seen before. He's got an intensity and speed that nobody has seen before. He's very much a modern-day player. He's created this new style of play.
"The only thing holding him back is his knees. It's a much healthier tennis circuit with him back in it."
This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.