Can Toshiba escape fate of corporate Japan's zombie hordes?

  • Published
A 'zombie walk' at a park in Tokyo on May 17, 2014Image source, Getty Images
Image caption,
Another of Japan's corporate behemoths faces the prospect of biting the dust

Once a household name, Toshiba is now bleeding billions of dollars and frantically trying to reassure investors that it will not succumb to the kiss of death.

But it also faces another fate: becoming the most high-profile member of Japan's corporate living dead, also known as zombie firms.

Toshiba admitted this week that its survival is at risk and that the firm could be delisted from the Tokyo stock exchange, following a major accounting scandal and an ill-timed bet on nuclear power.

The 142-year-old company is poised to record Japan's biggest industrial loss after its investment in US nuclear unit Westinghouse turned toxic.

So what's next? Well, a lot hinges on Toshiba's ability to raise much-needed cash through the sale of its valuable memory chip unit.

Here are three possible scenarios.

1. Walking dead - bailout

Toshiba is already the "walking dead" financially, says Gerhard Fasol, chief executive of Eurotechnology Japan: "Action should have been taken 20 years ago".

Zombie companies are loosely defined as loss-making or insolvent entities that should be allowed to fail, but continue to operate because of lenient creditors.

Thousands exist in Japan and the issue is considered to be a reason why Japan's economy risks suffering from a third "lost decade".

Media caption,

Why is Toshiba on the ropes?

All Toshiba needs now is a bailout from the Innovation Network Corporation of Japan (INCJ) or the Enterprise Turnaround Initiative Corporation, two government-backed bodies that rescue ailing companies, for this to happen.

However, many investors are not fans of this option. They argue that zombie firms need to be killed off, so that "creative destruction" can take place.

Amir Anvarzadeh of BGC Partners said if the government gets involved, "then we suspect we will find Toshiba back on the brink again sometime in the the future."

Want more proof of zombies? Not a single publicly-listed Japanese firm went bust last year. In fact, overall bankruptcies have fallen for eight years in a row.

Japan's Prime Minister, Shinzo Abe, touts those statistics as a sign of economic success, but being saved from going extinct is not necessarily a good thing.

Innovation and new firm creation remains incredibly low in Japan compared with other developed countries, according to OECD research.

2. Body parts - fire sale

Breaking up is hard to do. But Toshiba President Satoshi Tsunakawa has no other choice but to sell off some prized parts if he wants to keep the company afloat and alive.

Image source, Getty Images
Image caption,
Toshiba President Satoshi Tsunakawa (right) has a massive financial headache on his hands

Toshiba is in the process of auctioning off its semiconductor unit, which makes memory chips for smartphones, computers and other electronic devices.

It is the world's second-largest chip manufacturer behind Samsung, which is no mean feat, given how competitive the industry is.

Over the last two years, there has been an aggressive wave of consolidation. So when Toshiba's unit was put up for grabs, an array of interested bidders quickly assembled.

The chip unit is estimated to be worth between $9bn (£7.2bn) and $13bn. Taiwan's Foxconn, which assembles Apple's iPhones, has reportedly offered as much as $27bn.

Image source, Reuters

Foxconn also bought Japan's Sharp last year. But things could easily change.

The chip sale is now said to be facing opposition from various stakeholders, including US firm Western Digital, which has a joint venture deal with Toshiba.

The Japanese government is also believed to be reluctant to allow the sale of another company with proprietary technologies to a Chinese or South Korean rival.

BGC Partners' Mr Anvarzadeh dismisses the latter. "Arguments that technology transfer ultimately trickle down to China sound dubious," he says, adding that Taiwan and Korea have more advanced chip technologies anyway.

3. Off the menu - collapse

If the chip sale falls through, more accounting irregularities emerge or the banks decide to call in their loans, then all bets are off.

Toshiba could be allowed to fail. But that would have serious ramifications and will see thousands of shareholders lose their savings. Then there is the issue of national pride.

Toshiba launched the world's first mass-market laptop in 1985 and became known for its consumer electronics products such as televisions, although it is worth stating those units are no longer at the heart of its business and some are loss-making.

In addition, the decline of Japan Inc, once renowned the world over for its game-changing companies, has been going on for a long time now.

Image source, Getty Images
Image caption,
After 142 years of existence, is Toshiba now toast?

Analysts pretty much all agree that Toshiba is in a difficult, complicated situation. But they differ on the probable course of action.

Eurotechnology's Mr Fasol is predicting a "politically brokered solution", in which a US firm and a Japanese government investment fund acquire the chip company.

But Mr Anvarzadeh believes Toshiba should be allowed to sell the unit to Foxconn, because it is willing to pay the highest price.

"Pride is very expensive. I don't think the government can afford to be proud with Toshiba on the brink," he said.

"We think the best case scenario is for the Japanese government to stay out of this bidding process and, for once, allow market forces to run their course."

Follow Leisha on Twitter @BBCLeishaChi.