Education & Family

My student loan was mis-sold, says graduate

Simon Crowther Image copyright Simon Crowther Facebook
Image caption Simon Crowther says he never expected his student debt to be so high

An open letter from a graduate to his MP, showing how interest on his student loan has increased his debt by £1,800 in the year since he left university, has gone viral online.

Simon Crowther was in the first wave of students faced with £9,000 tuition fees and says he did not understand what he was doing when he took the loan at 18.

His letter to Vernon Coaker MP has been shared 38,000 times on Facebook.

The Student Loans Company says the interest rates were clearly set out.

Mr Crowther started a civil engineering degree at Nottingham University in 2012.

In the letter, also copied to the prime minister, he says that when he took out the loan he understood it would be at a very low interest rate of about 0.5%.

'No experience'

"I was still in the sixth form at school when I agreed to the student loan.

"I had no experience of loans, credit cards or mortgages.

"Like all the other thousands of students in the UK, we trusted the government that the interest rate would remain low."

He says he graduated last year "with a huge debt".

And since he graduated it has accrued interest at the rate of inflation - which is currently 0.9% - plus 3%.

Image copyright Simon Crowther Facebook

He says that in some months since then the interest has been more than £180, amounting to £1,828 in the year to March, with the total debt rising to £41,976.

"I feel we have been mis-sold the loan," he says in the letter.

The letter says that he believes the interest rates were hiked after the loans were sold to a private company - though this turns out to be incorrect.

Image copyright Simon Crowther Facebook
Image caption Mr Crowther's loan statement shows monthly interest is sometimes over £180

It has attracted almost 50,000 Facebook "likes" since it was posted on Tuesday.

One graduate said she had "nearly passed out" when her statement came through.

One comment suggested the possibility of a class action on the issue in the courts.

'Fair and sustainable'

But the government and Student Loans Company say the variable rate of interest, of inflation plus up to 3%, was made clear when the students first took out their loans.

"It is not the case that this individual's interest rate has increased or that their loan has been sold," said a Student Loans Company spokesman.

"The variable interest rates that would apply to his student loan are unchanged from those in force at the time of his application in 2012.

"All students that take out a loan must sign a declaration confirming that they have read the terms and conditions of the loan before it will be paid.

"These terms and conditions clearly set out the interest rates that the student will be charged, when they will start repaying and when interest starts accruing."


Student loan repayment guide

  • While studying, students in England and Wales are charged interest at inflation plus 3%, until the April after graduation
  • Graduates earning under £21,000 are charged interest at the rate of inflation
  • For those earning between £21,000 and £41,000 interest is inflation plus up to 3%, depending on income
  • And for those on over £41,000 it is inflation plus 3% maximum
  • Interest is set by governments and varies between administrations
  • Students repay loans at 9% of earnings above £21,000, a threshold frozen by the government last year
  • Loans are written off after 30 years
Image caption Students do not start paying off their loans until they earn £21,000 a year

The Department for Business, Innovation and Skills said the system was fair and sustainable "as the OECD has recognised".

"It removes financial barriers for anyone hoping to study and is backed by the taxpayer, with outstanding debt written off after 30 years.

"Graduates only pay back at 9% on earnings above £21,000 and enjoy a considerable wage premium of £9,500 per year over non-graduates," said the spokesman.

Related Topics

More on this story

Related Internet links

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites