Starmer: England's back-to-school plans 'lie in tatters'

By Hannah Richardson
Education and social affairs reporter

Chemistry lessonImage source, Getty Images
Image caption,
Chemistry experiments are difficult to replicate at home

Government plans for schooling during the pandemic "lie in tatters", with England's pupils set to miss six months of lessons, Sir Keir Starmer has said.

Calling for a national task force to tackle the issue, the Labour leader said the consequences for inequality and children's education were stark.

Boris Johnson defended the plan during Prime Minister's Questions, pledging extra support for vulnerable families.

Plans for all primary pupils to go back this term were ditched on Tuesday.

And although some secondary students, most of whom have been out of school since the end of March, are expected to be invited back for some face-to-face time with their teachers, their lessons are not expected to resume until September at the earliest.

Speaking during Wednesday's coronavirus briefing, Mr Johnson said the government "fully intends" to bring all children in England back to school in September "provided the progress we are making continues".

"What we'll be doing is a huge amount of catch-up for pupils over the summer months," he said, adding that the education secretary will announce more on a catch-up programme next week.

'Flailing around'

At PMQs, Sir Keir said Mr Johnson had announced his plan to reopen primaries on 1 June, without consulting head teachers or having convincing scientific evidence on safety.

And he said parents had lost confidence in the government's schools plan.

He accused the prime minister of "flailing around trying to blame others" for what had been a completely avoidable "mess".

Mr Johnson retaliated, during a series of testy exchanges, saying Sir Keir should ask "his friends in the left-wing trade unions", meaning the teachers' unions, to help schools prepare.

He also accused the Labour leader of changing his mind over whether schools should be open.

Sir Keir said England was an "outlier" compared with other countries in Europe, which had re-opened some of their schools.

And his attempts to set up a cross-party task force to tackle the issue had been ignored.


Ofsted chief inspector Amanda Spielman said the government's decision not to require all primary school pupils in England to return to the classroom before the summer holidays was "disappointing".

She told a House of Lords Committee she was "saddened" that people may have become "more frightened than they actually need to be".

Children's Commissioner Anne Longfield called for a national strategy to return pupils to classes, warning children risked being forgotten as the lockdown lifted.

And concerns were raised at the Commons Education Committee about the impact of school closures on children's life chances.

Prof Lee Elliot Major, former chief executive of the Sutton Trust education equality charity, said he was "really worried" about the eight million children currently out of school.

He said: "There is a tsunami of anxiety hitting schools about the one million children who are going to be taking their GCSEs and A-levels next year."

And there needed to be clarity about how public exams would be handled next year, adding that he preferred a combination of exams and teacher assessment.

Sally Collier, chief executive of England's exams watchdog, told the committee contingency plans were being drawn up but gave no details.

Reports have suggested Ofqual might be considering delaying exams or using a system involving predictive grades.

Image source, Getty Images

Ms Collier suggested the government may be re-thinking the content of exams for next year and that schools would need to know at the earliest opportunity what they were going to need to teach next year.

Ofqual would be publishing a consultation in the coming weeks on possible measures to ameliorate the impact of educational disruption on next year's exam candidates, she told MPs.

Other premises

National Education Union joint general secretary Kevin Courtney said it was increasingly clear disruption to schooling was going to continue.

"Looking at the exams system, we could face some of this, a very similar situation, next year, we have got to learn from this year," he said.

Dr Zubaida Haque, of the Runnymede Trust, said there needed to be an urgent look at what could be done for pupils who were not going back to school this summer.

She said there were lots of venues available out of school, which could be utilised because of Covid-19 restrictions - such as football stadiums, private schools and golf fields.

She urged ministers to think creatively and urgently about how such facilities could be used, with a view to setting up summer schools to help pupils catch up and support them with pastoral and emotional needs.

Meanwhile, the Welsh government has published new guidance on the measures schools should consider when reopening, including outside learning, teaching in small groups and pupils eating at their desks.

Schools in Wales will reopen to all age groups from 29 June but only a third of pupils will be in classes at any one time.

First Minister Nicola Sturgeon says Scottish schools will reopen from 11 August, using a blended model, with some continued home-learning.

In Northern Ireland, ministers have set a target date for some pupils to go back on 17 August, with a phased return for the rest in September.