Government publishes key vaccine report

  • Published
Faye BurdettImage source, Just Giving
Image caption,
Faye Burdett was taken to an accident and emergency unit with a rash on her forehead but died days later

A long-awaited report into how the government makes decisions about which vaccines to fund has been published.

It follows calls for greater transparency about why a vaccine to protect children against meningitis B was not made more widely available.

Two-year-old Faye Burdett died in 2016 - she was too old to have the vaccine.

An 820,000-signature petition calling for all children to be vaccinated was then submitted, - but the idea was rejected as "not cost effective".

One of the recommendations in the report is lowering the cost-effectiveness threshold for immunisation, potentially making it harder for new vaccines to be approved at current prices.

Health Minister Steven Brine was due to face questions from MPs on Tuesday over why the report into the cost-effectiveness of immunisations - promised by the end of 2016 - still had not been published.

Analysis - James Gallagher, health and science correspondent

The concern is that the proposals could put some current campaigns into question and make it harder for new ones to be set up.

That is certainly not what more than 800,000 people signed the Men B petition for.

Lowering the cost effectiveness threshold (economic speak for wanting more bang for your buck) will make it harder to justify paying for some expensive vaccines.

But other measures will make it easier.

At the moment the health benefits of vaccines, which are seen years later, are not given the same economic weight as drugs (such as in cancer) that deliver results immediately. Moves to cut this "discounting" of the benefits of vaccines would make it easier to fund them.

As would changing the rules to assess the effectiveness of a vaccine over the lifetime of a patient.

What the sum total of all these recommendations would mean is far from clear.

Commenting on the publication, Helen Jones, who chairs the Petitions Committee, said: "Since 2016, the Petitions and Health Committees have been urging the government to publish this report - so we are pleased that it has finally done so.

"It is, however, regrettable that the government has taken so long to act, when decisions about vaccines could save children's lives.

"Charities and campaigners, including families who have lost children to meningitis, have been left waiting for this report for far too long."

A consultation will now run until 21 May 2018.

Ms Jones said: "The government must now listen to the voices of survivors and bereaved families."

Faye's parents, Jenny and Neil Burdett, have said they "remain disappointed and frustrated that the government deemed the protection of vulnerable children as 'not cost effective'.

"We had hoped our collective voices would be heard and changes made," they said.

"We are disgusted with the health department for the way they have treated one of the biggest petitions to date."

Image source, Just Giving / Charlene Reed
Image caption,
Faye Burdett died on Valentine's Day 2016, after fighting the bacterial infection for 11 days

They made public photos of Faye in hospital to raise awareness of the bacterial infection.

And the petition the images featured in became the most popular petition in parliamentary history. It is now the third largest.

Meningitis Research Foundation chief executive Vinny Smith, said: "Two years is too long, but we are pleased to see a public consultation on the report which has finally been published.

"We are taking time to review the report in full but are concerned that some recommendations would be detrimental to future vaccines and could reduce our chances of preventing serious and fatal illnesses."

Meningitis B

  • Meningitis B is a bacterial infection that most often affects children younger than one
  • Since 2015, children under 12 months have been offered the vaccination
  • There are about 1,200 meningitis B cases each year in the UK
  • Symptoms include a high fever with cold hands and feet, confusion, vomiting and headaches
  • But a recent study warns fever might not be present and to look out for poor feeding, lethargy and irritability too
  • With early diagnosis and antibiotic treatment, most people will make a full recovery
  • It is fatal in one in 10 cases
  • About one in four of those who survive is left with long-term problems, such as amputation, deafness, epilepsy and learning difficulties

Related Internet Links

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.