Health screening 'not meeting targets', report finds

Image source, Getty Images

None of the three main health screening programmes in England - for bowel, breast or cervical cancer - met their targets last year, according to a report by the National Audit Office.

There were also delays in cervical screening results reaching half of women tested, with a backlog of nearly 100,000 samples.

Bowel screening performed best, narrowly missing its 60% target.

A health think tank said the report was "deeply concerning".

But ministers said they were committed to making improvements to keep screening programmes "among the best in the world".

The NAO report comes after two recent incidents with breast and cervical screening raised concerns about about the management and organisation of both programmes.

Smear result delays

While bowel and breast screening met their minimum targets in 2017-18, neither met their upper target for the percentage of eligible people screened for signs of cancer.

However, with 72% of women eligible for cervical screening being tested last year, even the lower target of 75% was not met.

Many women also experienced delays getting their results after having smear tests, or cervical screening.

According to the Department of Health and Social Care, results should be received within 14 days, but this target has not been met since 2015.

In March 2018, a third of women received their results on time, improving to just over half (55%) by the end of last year.

But in October, 98,628 samples were still waiting to be tested in labs across England, the report said.

It is thought that a change in the way tests are carried out affected staffing in labs, leading to the delays.

Image source, Getty Images
Image caption,
Half of women experienced delays receiving their cervical screening results

The report also highlights variation in the percentage of people screened across the country, with the lowest levels of coverage mostly in London.

And it describes issues with complex, ageing IT systems, with the cervical screening programme relying on an estimated 350 different systems to make it work.

Complicated IT problems are reported to have resulted in 5,000 women not being invited for breast screening.

The report also raises questions about the way screening programmes are governed and monitored.

However, the report says NHS England and Public Health England have succeeded in introducing bowel scope screening, although only half of GP practices were linked to a screening centre delivering the service in 2016-17.

By September 2018, 166,000 people had been invited for this type of screening against a target of nearly 500,000.


Rebecca Fisher, a GP and policy fellow at the Health Foundation, said the report painted "a deeply concerning picture of the state of screening programmes in England, with missed targets, inconsistent coverage, and ageing IT systems".

She said screening saved lives but the public must be able to trust the quality of the services being offered.

Image source, Getty Images
Image caption,
The report said complicated IT systems were one reason for screening delays and errors

"Today's report highlights an urgent need for investment in the IT and equipment required to make improvements," she said.

"Policymakers must also consider how to most efficiently run screening programmes to ensure that these potentially lifesaving services are equally available right across the country."

Meg Hillier, chairwoman of the MPs' committee of public accounts, said: "Those responsible for screening programmes are not always capable of picking up when people are not invited for a screening appointment, or ensuring that people receive their test results on time.

"It is unacceptable that these important screening programmes are being let down by complex and ageing IT. The Department of Health and Social Care, NHS England and Public Health England need to get this fixed."

A Department of Health and Social Care spokesperson said: "Our screening programmes are widely recognised as among the best in the world, and we are committed to making any improvements needed to keep our offer to patients world-class.

"Prevention and early diagnosis of cancer are key priorities for this government, and we are already working closely with NHS England and Public Health England to address the issues this useful report highlights."

More on this story

Related Internet Links

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.