WhatsApp must not be 'place for terrorists to hide'

  • Published
Media caption,

Amber Rudd: "Intelligence services need to be able to get into encrypted services like WhatsApp"

There must be "no place for terrorists to hide" and intelligence services must have access to encrypted messaging services, the home secretary has said.

Khalid Masood killed four people in Westminster this week. It is understood his phone had connected to messaging app WhatsApp two minutes earlier.

Amber Rudd said she would be meeting technology firms this week.

A WhatsApp spokeswoman said the company was "horrified at the attack" and was co-operating with the investigation.

Meanwhile, a 12th arrest has been made by officers investigating the attack. The 30-year-man was detained in Birmingham on Sunday on suspicion of preparing terrorist acts.

All messages sent on WhatsApp have end-to-end encryption, meaning they are unreadable if intercepted by anyone, including law enforcement and WhatsApp itself.

So while Masood's phone is believed to have connected with the app, police may not know what, if anything, was communicated.

Speaking to BBC One's Andrew Marr Show, Ms Rudd said: "It is completely unacceptable, there should be no place for terrorists to hide.

"We need to make sure that organisations like WhatsApp, and there are plenty of others like that, don't provide a secret place for terrorists to communicate with each other.

"It used to be that people would steam open envelopes or just listen in on phones when they wanted to find out what people were doing, legally, through warrantry.

"But on this situation we need to make sure that our intelligence services have the ability to get into situations like encrypted WhatsApp."

Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn said authorities already had "huge powers".

There had to be a balance between the "right to know" and "the right to privacy", he said.

Image caption,
Masood was born Adrian Elms in Dartford, Kent

The Facebook-owned company, which has a billion users worldwide, has said previously that protecting private communication is one of its "core beliefs".

Tim Cook, the chief executive of Apple which also uses end-to-end encryption, has previously said it would be "wrong" for governments to force Apple to "build a back door" into products.

But Ms Rudd said: "I would ask Tim Cook to think again about other ways of helping us work out how we can get into the situations like WhatsApp on the Apple phone."

Europol director Rob Wainwright echoed Ms Rudd's call for changes.

"I would agree something has to be done to make sure that we can apply a more consistent form of interception of communication in all parts of the way in which terrorists invade our lives," he told Andrew Neil on the BBC's Sunday Politics.

Image source, PA/Facebook
Image caption,
PC Keith Palmer, Kurt Cochran and Aysha Frade all died in the attack (left to right)

The victims of the Westminster attack were commemorated at the beginning of England's World Cup qualifier against Lithuania at Wembley Stadium.

Before kick-off, four wreaths were laid in the centre of the pitch by Metropolitan Police Acting Commissioner Craig Mackey, London Mayor Sadiq Khan, FA chairman Greg Clarke and Culture Secretary Karen Bradley.

A minute's silence was also observed by fans and players.

Image source, PA
Image caption,
Four wreaths for the four victims of the Westminster attack were laid in the centre of Wembley Stadium's pitch before England's World Cup qualifier with Lithuania

Masood, 52, killed three people and injured 50 when he drove a car into pedestrians on Westminster Bridge on Wednesday.

He then fatally stabbed a police officer before being shot dead by police - all within 82 seconds.

Ms Rudd would not confirm who shot Masood, amid claims it was a bodyguard for Defence Secretary Sir Michael Fallon.

Can the government access encrypted data?

Media caption,

What is encryption?

A provider could co-operate with authorities and decrypt data, says Will Knight, a senior editor at MIT Technology Review. But done properly, encrypted data can be difficult or impossible to access.

WhatsApp maintains only those involved in a message can read the contents due to end-to-end encryption.

There are sometimes "backdoors", Mr Knight says, and intelligence services have exploited those to retrieve the keys needed to decrypt messages. But backdoors may then be exploited by criminals, or hostile governments.

Prof Ross Anderson, from Cambridge University, points out that if companies do co-operate, and try to keep quiet about it, it won't take long for the tech-savvy to cotton on.

And criminals or terrorists will merely divert to one of the many other messaging services, based overseas, he adds.

Scotland Yard has said it believes Masood acted alone, and while officers were "determined" to find out whether he had been inspired by terrorist propaganda, it was possible his motive would never be known.

A 58-year-old man, who was arrested in Birmingham the morning after the attack under the Terrorism Act, remains in custody, while a 32-year-old woman arrested in Manchester remains on police bail.

Eleven people were initially arrested over the incident and nine people in total have been released without charge.

82-second attack

  • 14:40:08 - the car that Masood was driving over Westminster Bridge first mounted the pavement on the northbound side
  • 14:40:38 - after continuing towards Bridge Street along both the footpath and road, Masood crashes into the perimeter fence of the Palace of Westminster
  • 14:40:59 - the first 999 call was made to the Met police reporting the incident
  • 14:41:30 - Masood left the vehicle and was shot by a police firearms officer inside the Palace of Westminster