Devonport nuclear base has special measures extended

Media playback is unsupported on your device
Media captionThe UK's nuclear submarine refit base is to remain in special measures amid safety concerns

The UK's nuclear submarine refit base is to remain in special measures amid safety concerns.

The Office for Nuclear Regulation (ONR) has also warned Devonport in Plymouth might need enhanced monitoring until 2020 unless improvements are made.

Special measures, including monthly inspections, were predicted to last two years when first imposed in 2013.

Babcock, which carries out the refitting for the Ministry of Defence, said safety was its "highest priority".

The ONR said its "enhanced regulatory attention" meant the once-a-month inspections of HMNB Devonport had "more effort and managerial attention".

Image caption Devonport naval base has been warned of legal action after a series of safety breaches

Its latest annual report blames safety concerns on "ageing facilities" and "increasing demands" as well as "stretched resources" for an unscheduled refuelling of HMS Vanguard later this year.

Last December, Babcock was warned of legal action after a worker received a dose of radiation amid a series of safety breaches.


  • "Range of ageing facilities"
  • "Increasing demands from submarine maintenance"
  • "Stretched resources, particularly given the government decision to refuel HMS Vanguard"
  • "December 2014, ONR issued an Improvement Notice following a formal investigation into a loss of control of radioactive material"
  • Improvements likely to require "sustained commitment over the next three to five years"

When Devonport was first placed under special measures in 2013, the ONR said the base was "expected to receive enhanced regulatory attention for around two years, as we anticipate the issues to be resolved during that time".

It added with "sustained commitment over the next three to five years", Devonport "has the potential to move to a routine attention position".

Image copyright MOD
Image caption Refuelling HMS Vanguard later this year has led to "stretched resources" for the dockyard

Peter Burt, of the Nuclear Information Service, said: "The nuclear safety improvements required at Devonport have not been completed within the expected two year timescale, and we will apparently have to wait for several more years before the situation improves.

"Babcock is clearly unable to deliver the improvements it is being paid to complete. It is time for the MoD to cancel the current management contract for the dockyard and bring the site under the control of a new, competent management team."


  • Devonport, the largest naval base in western Europe, has been supporting the Royal Navy since 1691
  • The vast site covers more than 650 acres and has 15 dry docks, four miles of waterfront, 25 tidal berths and five basins
  • Employs 2,500 service personnel and civilians, supports about 400 local firms and generates about 10% of Plymouth's income

Source: MoD

Babcock said in a statement: "The continued safety of our operations at Devonport remains the highest priority.

"We have developed a comprehensive long term safety improvement programme to address the points raised by ONR. That work is progressing to plan and has the full visibility of the regulators."

The Ministry of Defence said: "Safety at HM Naval Base Devonport, as with all Ministry of Defence sites, is of paramount importance.

"The MoD supports Babcock's commitment to address the issues raised in the report, and we continue to work together to deliver the necessary investments at Devonport, which includes a site-wide nuclear safety programme with sustained commitment over the coming years."

More on this story

Related Internet links

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites