Northern Ireland

Union flag protest policing unacceptable: Terry Spence

Media playback is unsupported on your device
Media captionTerry Spence said tougher action should have been taken

The union that represents rank and file police officers in Northern Ireland has said the way the PSNI dealt with union flag protests was unacceptable.

Terry Spence, chairman of the Police Federation, said tougher action should have been taken during disturbances, including early use of plastic bullets.

Loyalist protests followed Belfast City Council's vote to limit the flying of the union flag from city hall.

Scores of police officers were injured and many roads were closed.

Two hundred and forty six people have been arrested, 188 of whom have been charged.

"There has been a tactical operational failure in how we first handled these public order confrontations," Mr Spence said.

"To put it bluntly, we were policing public order in Northern Ireland according to guidelines more appropriate for the rest of the UK," Mr Spence said.

"The sight of AEPs (plastic bullets) tends to concentrate the minds of potential rioters.

"Too often, it is fear of adverse comment from our politicians that inhibits senior officers from fulfilling their duty of care to the men and women on the ground."

'Not cannon fodder'

Mr Spence said that since July of last year, 448 PSNI officers had been injured as a result of public disorder. According to the PSNI, 147 of those have been injured in violence linked to flag protests.

"As a force the PSNI seem to have taken comfort in the mistaken belief that no officers have been seriously injured at these regular scenes of public disorder," he said.

"We are not cannon fodder."

Image caption Dozens of police officers were injured during disturbances linked to flag protests

Chief Constable Matt Baggott previously defended the PSNI decision to allow flag protesters to block roads and take part in illegal parades.

He said robust action to clear roads could have resulted in serious public disorder.

The chief constable's approach was strongly criticised at the annual conference of the Police Federation in County Down on Wednesday.

'Fear of confrontation'

Mr Spence also condemned the fact that UVF flags have not been removed from several parts of east Belfast.

"It is unacceptable to us as police officers, or indeed to the community, that we appear reluctant to enforce the law because of the fear of provoking uncontainable confrontation with the (loyalist paramilitary) UVF bully boys," Mr Spence said.

"Our politicians and our police service need to address the perception in the wider community by clearly demonstrating that we are standing up to the UVF as well as the dissident republicans."

Mr Spence also criticised some Northern Ireland politicians for their stance on contentious parades.

"The police service will do its job, but we would be greatly assisted if elected representatives, especially, understood that they cannot choose which laws they will obey and that the decisions of the Parades Commission are the law," he said.

The conference heard Mr Spence describe republican dissidents as a "sad group of misfits who cannot accept that violence in pursuit of any political objective, has no place in any democracy".

He said it was only due to good luck and excellent police work that officers had not been injured or killed in recent dissident attacks.

Deputy Chief Constable Judith Gillespie said police at the time were put in an impossible situation during the flag protests.

"There are things that, perhaps with the benefit of hindsight, if we'd known this was going to go on for so long, if we'd known that certain things were going to happen in between, of course there are things we might have done differently," she said.

"But at a strategic level I'm confident we were doing the right things.

Media playback is unsupported on your device
Media captionDeputy Chief Constable Judith Gillespie defended her officers' response

"I stand by the actions of my officers, both those who were in charge of the operation and those who were on the ground."

Justice Minister David Ford, who addressed the conference after Mr Spence, commended the PSNI's policing of flag protests.

"It is the good work of police in demonstrating that breaking the law has consequences that has sobered up protesters," he said.

He said he wanted to help build a shared future for all the people of Northern Ireland "in which everyone is free to live and learn, work and play, in safety".

"The PSNI is central to delivering this vision of a truly united and integrated community and I thank you and all your colleagues for the contribution that they make," he said.

"I will continue to work to ensure that politicians live up to their responsibilities and do not demand that police officers have to step in because of failure of leadership elsewhere."

More on this story