UK Politics

Julian Smith: Chief whip attacks cabinet's post-election Brexit strategy

Media playback is unsupported on your device
Media captionThe chief whip, Julian Smith: "The government should have been clearer on the consequences"

The government should have made clear after the 2017 election that it would "inevitably" have to accept a closer relationship with the EU after Brexit, the Conservative chief whip has said.

In a BBC documentary, Julian Smith - who manages party discipline - is also critical of the cabinet's behaviour.

The attack comes as the cabinet is split over whether to move to a softer deal that could mean a customs union.

No 10 said the prime minister had "never used the term soft Brexit".

Several cabinet ministers have said agreeing to a customs union would break promises the Conservatives made at the 2017 election while ex-minister Steve Baker said doing so would "shatter" the party.

MPs will hold further votes later on Brexit options to try and resolve the current deadlock. A customs union with the EU is thought to be the most popular of the ideas under consideration.

Other options include leaving the EU without a deal on 12 April, a referendum to rule out no deal and a confirmatory referendum on Prime Minister Theresa May's deal.

Media playback is unsupported on your device
Media captionThe chief whip: "worst example" of cabinet ill-discipline in British political history

Culture Minister Margot James told the BBC's Politics Live she was considering voting for the referendum option as although she still believed the PM's deal was the best on offer, the chances of it being approved were "receding".

In interviews for The Brexit Storm: Laura Kuenssberg's Inside Story, Mr Smith accused ministers of trying to undermine the prime minister.

He said he witnessed ministers "sitting around the cabinet table... trying to destabilise her [Mrs May]" and described their behaviour as the "worst example of ill-discipline in cabinet in British political history".

Media playback is unsupported on your device
Media captionThe treasury secretary says she doesn't fear a no deal Brexit

Mr Smith said that when his party failed to get a majority in the 2017 election, which ended in a Hung Parliament, "the government as a whole probably should have just been clearer on the consequences of that".

The parliamentary arithmetic after the poll, he added, meant "that this would be inevitably a kind of softer type of Brexit".

But Chief Secretary to the Treasury Liz Truss said it was not clear a customs union could get a parliamentary majority, as it does not have the backing of the SNP and some Labour MPs.

"It's not clear to me that going softer is the way to command support," she told Radio 4's Today, adding "the "answer lies in modifications to the prime minister's deal".

Please upgrade your browser

Environment Secretary Michael Gove said signing up to a customs union would "compromise" pledges made in 2017 while Defence Secretary Gavin Williamson said ministers were "determined" to avoid that happening.

Labour has said it will this time support the Common Market 2.0 option in Monday's votes, in addition to other options which the party backed last week.

This option would mean joining the European Free Trade Association and European Economic Area, with countries such as Norway, and it includes single market membership and retains freedom of movement.

In the last vote, 58 Labour MPs abstained and 42 voted against this proposal.

Julian Smith has told the BBC that the government ought to have admitted after the election that it would inevitably have to move to a softer Brexit, saying ministers should have been clearer about the consequences of losing their majority then.

But here's the tricky thing - the prime minister has never acknowledged publicly that she might have to soften up her deal. And many Conservatives, including some in cabinet, believe it would be unacceptable to do so.

Mr Smith, and others in government, suggest the prime minister might still put her deal back in front of MPs, perhaps as early as this week. Whips are, hypothetically, the keepers of secrets inside government. But in these turbulent times, few conventions still apply.

Read Laura's blog in full here.

A customs union would allow businesses to move goods around the EU without tariffs - taxes on importing goods - but membership would bar the UK from striking independent trade deals after Brexit.

The prime minister has until 12 April to seek a longer extension to the Article 50 process if the UK is to avoid leaving without a deal.

Media playback is unsupported on your device
Media captionConfused by Brexit jargon? Reality Check unpacks the basics.

Parliament has rejected the withdrawal agreement the UK has negotiated - covering the UK's "divorce bill", guarantees on citizens' rights and contingency plans for the Irish border known as the backstop - with the EU three times.

European Parliament's Brexit co-ordinator Guy Verhofstadt tweeted that Brexit was a "tragic reality" and urged MPs to find a compromise in Monday's votes.

In an attempt to force the government's hand, MPs will hold their second non-binding vote later on a series of options to see if any of them can command a majority in Parliament.


None of MPs' eight proposed options secured a majority in the first set of indicative votes on 27 March, but those that received the greatest support were a customs union with the EU and a referendum on any deal.

Mrs May's deal is opposed by parties including Northern Ireland's DUP - which the government relies upon for support - as well as a group of her own MPs.

The DUP has said it will not vote for the deal as it believes it could threaten Northern Ireland's place in the UK.

The party's Brexit spokesman, MP Sammy Wilson, said it would not back it even if Mrs May brings it for a vote in the Commons "1,000 times".

The Brexit Storm: Laura Kuenssberg's Inside Story will be broadcast on Monday 1 April at 21:00 BST on BBC2


What next?

  • Monday, 1 April: MPs hold another set of votes on Brexit options to see if they can agree on a way forward
  • Wednesday, 3 April: Potentially another round of so-called "indicative votes"
  • Wednesday, 10 April: Emergency summit of EU leaders to consider any UK request for further extension
  • Friday, 12 April: Brexit day, if UK does not seek/EU does not grant further delay
  • 23-26 May: European Parliamentary elections

More on this story