Australia ex-judge Jim Macken offers swap with refugee

  • Published
A file picture dated dated 21 March 2014 shows asylum seekers behind a fence at the Manus Island detention centre, in Papua New GuineaImage source, EPA
Image caption,
Media access to Manus Island or Nauru is rare. Here asylum seekers line up along a fence at Manus camp

A retired judge in Australia has offered to swap places with a refugee and live the rest of his life in one of the country's offshore detention camps.

Jim Macken, who is 88, said he had written to Immigration Minister Peter Dutton to offer a "body swap".

"I understand this is an unusual request but I offer it in complete sincerity," Mr Macken wrote.

Australia processes migrants and refugees on the Pacific island of Nauru and on Manus island, Papua New Guinea.

The government has faced heavy criticism over conditions at the detention centres, both of which are run by private companies.

Image source, Getty Images
Image caption,
Nauru, the world's smallest republic, holds one of Australia's migrant camps

In the letter, seen by Australian media, Mr Macken said: "My reason for making this proposal is simple. I can no longer remain silent as innocent men, women and children are being held in appalling circumstances on Manus Island and Nauru.

"It is even worse that they are being held in these dangerous and inhospitable conditions in order to ensure no other asylum seekers and refugees attempt to come to Australia for protection.

"The Australian government is essentially treating refugees in these camps as human shields and this is utterly immoral. As this is being done in my name I cannot remain silent.

"I offer this proposal as a way forward for at least one refugee. This would allow one person currently held on Manus Island or Nauru the right to be an Australian citizen. I would consider it a privilege to live out my final years in either Nauru or Manus Island in his or her stead."

Media caption,

Life in the Nauru detention centre

Mr Macken reportedly offered to relinquish his Australian citizenship if necessary.

A spokeswoman for Mr Dutton said the minister's office was checking to see if it had received the letter, which was sent a month ago, and declined to comment further.

Mr Macken also wrote to Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull and Labor party leader Bill Shorten, urging them to "err on the side of compassion and justice" and end offshore processing.

A spokesman for the prime minister declined to comment.

Speaking to the Guardian, Mr Macken said he had "nothing to lose" by making his offer.

"If it gets just one refugee off one of those islands, and gives them a chance at a life in Australia, I'm prepared to do it," he said.

He said he wasn't seeking publicity and would be happy to undertake the exchange without notifying the public.

Mr Macken was a barrister and union organiser until his retirement in 1989. He was appointed a member of the Order of Australia in 2003.

Australia and asylum

Image source, Amnesty International
Image caption,
A photo taken by Amnesty International shows the inside of a tent housing asylum seekers in Nauru
  • The number of asylum seekers travelling to Australia by boat rose sharply in 2012 and early 2013. Scores of people have died making the journey.
  • To stop the influx, the government adopted tough measures intended as a deterrent.
  • Everyone who arrives is detained. Under the policy, asylum seekers are processed offshore at centres on Nauru and Manus Island in Papua New Guinea.
  • The government has also adopted a policy of tow-backs, or turning boats around.