EU-US TTIP trade talks hit investor protection snag

EU Trade Commissioner Cecilia Malmstroem, 13 Jan 15 Image copyright AFP
Image caption The TTIP project is a tough challenge for EU Trade Commissioner Cecilia Malmstroem

EU-US talks aimed at clinching a comprehensive free trade deal have run up against "huge scepticism" in Europe, the European Commission says.

The Commission has published the results of a public consultation on investor protection - one of the most contentious areas under discussion.

There were many objections to the idea of using independent tribunals with power to overrule national policies.

A lot of work is needed on future investment rules, the Commission says.

The talks on a Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership Agreement (TTIP) are continuing, but the important area of investor protection has been suspended for now.

There are widespread fears in Europe that EU standards might be weakened in some areas, in a trade-off to satisfy powerful business lobbies and revive Europe's struggling economies.

A Commission study estimates that a TTIP deal could boost the size of the EU economy by €120bn (£94bn; $152bn) - equal to 0.5% of the 28-member bloc's total GDP - and the US economy by €95bn (0.4% of GDP).

But the Commission acknowledges public concern about court cases in which powerful companies have sued governments over public policy.

Swedish energy giant Vattenfall brought a claim against the German government over its move to decommission nuclear power plants.

And US tobacco giant Philip Morris sued the Australian government over the introduction of plain packaging for cigarettes.

In the UK concern has focused on the National Health Service and the possible involvement of US firms in healthcare services.

Of the total responses in the consultation 35% came from the UK - the largest share - and Austria was second.

Image copyright EPA
Image caption Last month Brussels saw a big anti-TTIP protest by farmers and NGOs

Role of tribunals

EU governments have agreed to include investor-to-state dispute settlement (ISDS) in the final TTIP deal.

But ISDS, involving independent arbitration in commercial disputes, has not yet been agreed by the European Parliament, which will have to approve any final text. And now the Commission says a decision on ISDS will have to wait until the final phase of the TTIP talks.

In international trade deals foreign investors usually get:

  • Protection against discrimination (no national favouritism)
  • Protection against arbitrary or unfair expropriation
  • Protection over fair legal procedures
  • Guarantees to allow transfers of capital

Some public services, including government procurement rules, can be excluded from such deals.

Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker says the plan is to reach a TTIP deal by the end of this year.

"The consultation clearly shows that there is huge scepticism against the ISDS instrument," EU Trade Commissioner Cecilia Malmstroem said.

"We need to have an open and frank discussion about investment protection and ISDS in TTIP with EU governments, with the European Parliament and civil society before launching any policy recommendations in this area."

ISDS is already a widely-used mechanism in international trade. But the Commission says it wants the TTIP rules to be exemplary, and not jeopardising EU standards or governments' right to regulate.

The Commission says it received nearly 150,000 public responses - an "unprecedented" number for an EU consultation. But many were identical responses submitted by pressure groups (NGOs). A UK campaign group, 38 Degrees, submitted 50,000 responses.

There were 3,144 replies from individuals and 450 from organisations, including businesses, trade unions, consumer groups, law firms and academics.

In a transparency drive the Commission has published the texts of its TTIP negotiating positions for various topics, such as competition rules, sustainable development and specific industries.

More on this story