BBC News

Israel US: Republican invite to Netanyahu riles Obama

By Kevin Connolly
BBC Middle East correspondent

image copyrightAFP
image captionThe White House is said to be furious at Benjamin Netanyahu's invitation to Congress

In a world of shifting diplomatic sands, the relationship between the United States and Israel feels like a fixed point.

The two countries share military and political intelligence and Israeli politicians tend to portray their country as a kind of branch office of the Free World, operating the franchise in a particularly tough neighbourhood.

America provides money and weapons for the defence of the Jewish State and is bound to its main ally in the Middle East by countless links, both public and private.

Pro-Israeli lobbying organisations like the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (Aipac) are influential power-brokers in the election of many members of Congress and money flows into Israel from Jewish-American charities and wealthy individuals.

So when there is a blip in the relationship, it is news and there is certainly a blip now, if not something slightly more serious.

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has accepted an invitation to speak to Congress on 3 March - exactly two weeks before Israelis vote in a parliamentary election in which he is seeking a fourth term of office.

The invitation came not from the White House - which is furious at being blind-sided - but from the Speaker of the House, the Republican John Boehner.

image copyrightEPA
image captionMr Netanyahu was invited to Congress by the Republican House speaker, John Boehner

Mr Netanyahu's rivals at home are also furious. They believe this is not about the fierce urgency of Iran's nuclear ambitions - which will be Mr Netanyahu's subject - but simply about Mr Netanyahu's conservative ideological soul mates on Capitol Hill giving him a leg-up before polling day on one of the world's most glamorous political stages.

That issue - Iran and the Bomb - is one of the defining themes of Mr Netanyahu's career and he is alarmed that the P5+1 powers (the five permanent members of the UN Security Council - the US, Russia, China, UK and France - plus Germany) negotiating with Tehran may be preparing to agree a deal towards the end of March which would be acceptable to the world powers but unacceptable to Israel.

So he will have plenty to talk about when he stands up in Congress.

Body language test

The Obama administration does not much care for Mr Netanyahu at the best of times. It does not support his judgment on the Iran issue but there is something more too.

In siding with the Republicans and against the White House, in a speech to Congress, it may look as though he is intervening in US domestic politics.

And by inviting him to speak as his election campaign in Israel reaches a climax, it looks as though House Republicans are intervening in Israel.

Last year an unnamed US official was quoted as calling Mr Netanyahu "a chickenshit" - this time the administration has confined itself to calling his decision to speak in Congress "destructive".

But is this the worst relations between the two countries have ever been, as Senator John McCain has said? Probably not.

The US fell out with Israel spectacularly under Eisenhower (over Suez) and under Ford, Reagan and George HW Bush. Things got pretty bad in the 50s, the 70s and the 90s.

They recovered then and they will recover this time but it will be interesting to study the body language the next time Mr Obama and Mr Netanyahu meet. That will not be on this trip. Too close to Israel's elections, said the White House.

The bottom line is this: Mr Netanyahu's speech to Congress has caused quite a political flap even before he has got to his feet and cleared his throat.

He had better make sure he has something memorable to say.

Related Topics

  • Republican Party
  • Iran
  • Barack Obama
  • United States
  • Israel
  • Benjamin Netanyahu

More on this story

  • Netanyahu row with Obama administration deepens