Europe

In pictures: A history of US-Russian summits

When US President Donald Trump met his Russian counterpart Vladimir Putin in the Finnish capital, Helsinki, on 16 July 2018, they entered their names into the pages of a long history of talks between US and Soviet or Russian leaders.

Here we look back at the summits that preceded this one.

President John F. Kennedy greeting Premier Nikita S. Khrushchev of the Soviet Union at the United States Embassy in Vienna in 1961. Image copyright Getty Images
Image caption John F Kennedy was furious with himself after his meeting with Soviet leader Nikita Khrushchev

President John F Kennedy met Soviet Premier Nikita Khrushchev in Vienna in 1961. The talks were dominated by the crisis in Berlin and control over the divided city. For Kennedy, it was a bruising, unexpectedly hostile encounter at which he felt outmatched by his Soviet counterpart.

"Worst thing in my life," the president told a New York Times reporter after the talks. "He savaged me." The Berlin Wall went up in the months after the talks and the following year the two superpowers locked horns over the Cuban missile crisis.

President Nixon and Soviet Premier Brezhnev shake hands after signing the first Salt treaty. Image copyright Getty Images
Image caption Richard Nixon met Leonid Brezhnev, who was the Soviet premier for 18 years

In May 1972, President Richard Nixon and Soviet leader Leonid Brezhnev met in Moscow for their first summit, which produced what appeared to be a good working relationship between the two leaders and a historic arms treaty setting limits to the rapidly expanding nuclear arsenals of both powers.

Nixon invited Brezhnev to Washington the following year, and the pair signed nuclear arms control treaties at three successive summits.

US President Gerald Ford and Soviet leader Leonid Brezhnev seen during the welcome ceremony at Vladivostok airport. Image copyright Getty Images
Image caption Gerald Ford with Brezhnev, who often kept to the traditional socialist greeting of kisses

In November 1974, Nixon's successor Gerald Ford met Brezhnev for the first time in the Russian city of Vladivostok. Relations between the pair were warm despite the extreme cold. They discussed American football and football which they had respectively played as younger men, and joked together.

Ford had come wearing a wolfskin coat from Alaska. "I'm a sheep in wolf's clothing," he joked to reporters. "I told the first secretary. I'm going to get him one." Brezhnev then tried on the coat and modelled it for photographers.

US President Gerald Ford with Soviet leader Leonid Brezhnev at the Vladivostok Summit USSR November 23rd 1974. Image copyright Getty Images
Image caption Brezhnev tries on Gerald Ford's Alaskan wolfskin coat for the cameras

The pair met again the following year in Helsinki - the first of several US-Russian summits that would take place in the Finnish capital - for the Conference on Security and Co-operation in Europe.

Leaders from 35 nations signed the Helsinki accords - a declaration which called for respect for human rights and for the inviolability of European borders. It was among the most significant moments of the Cold War, but Ford faced criticism at home for what was seen by some as a concession to the Soviets and a legitimisation of Soviet oppression in Eastern Europe.

Jan Lodal, a member of Ford's policy team at the summit, later wrote in the Atlantic that Brezhnev had secretly told Ford that the Soviets supported his re-election and would "do everything we can to make that happen". It would turn out to be a strange foreshadowing of the build up to another US presidential election, 41 years later.

President Gerald Ford and Soviet leader and Communist Party chief Leonid Brezhnev in Vladivostok on Nov. 24, 1974. Image copyright Getty Images
Image caption Brezhnev (r) had a "Slavic love of physical contact", including bear hugs, US memos for Ford (l) revealed

Towards the end of the Cold War, in December 1987, President Ronald Reagan and Soviet leader Mikhail Gorbachev met in Washington DC, where the two nations once again engaged on the issue of controlling nuclear arms stockpiles and testing.

They signed the INF Treaty - an accord banning intermediate-range nuclear missiles which led to the destruction of 2,692 missiles by 1991.

General Secretary Mikhail S. Gorbachev of the Soviet Union and President Ronald Reagan sign the Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces Treaty at the White House on December 8, 1987. Image copyright Getty Images
Image caption General Secretary Mikhail Gorbachev and President Ronald Reagan are widely credited for ending the Cold War era

Then last year, shortly before the INF Treaty's 30-year anniversary, President Trump accused Russian leader Vladimir Putin of violating the pact by testing and deploying a ground-launched intermediate-range cruise missile, calling it a "big deal".

Moscow responded by accusing the US of violating the treaty.

Soviet President Mikhail Gorbachev (left) and US President George HW Bush hold a joint press conference in the White House's East Room, Washington DC, June 3, 1990. (Photo by Ron Sachs Image copyright Getty Images

President George HW Bush met Mr Gorbachev seven times. By the time they met for their third summit, in Helsinki in September 1990, they had established a warm working relationship based on hours of discussions, often without advisers.

Mr Bush was hoping to shore up support from Mr Gorbachev in dealing with aggression by the Iraqi leader Saddam Hussein, who had weeks earlier invaded Kuwait.

Mr Gorbachev arrived at the summit with a gift for Mr Bush - a framed cartoon depicting the two leaders as boxers, both standing in a victory stance, having knocked out a prone figure labelled "Cold War" in Russian.

President of the USSR Mikhail Gorbachev presents US President George Bush (R) a friendly jest of a Soviet painter. Image copyright Getty Images
Image caption Mr Gorbachev presents Mr Bush with a cartoon to commemorate the end of the Cold War...
Mikhail Gorbachev presents George Bush with a harmless caricature painted by a Soviet painter. Image copyright Getty Images
Image caption ...and gets a good laugh from the US president

President Bill Clinton met Russian leader Boris Yeltsin in Helsinki in March 1997 for talks viewed as some of the most crucial between the US and Russia since the end of the Cold War. Relations had been strained by an eastward expansion of Nato to include former Soviet bloc nations.

Yeltsin made it clear at the summit that he objected to Nato enlargement, but agreed to negotiate a pact with the alliance. The pair also agreed to a sharp reduction in their respective nuclear arsenals.

Clinton and Yeltsin 1997 Image copyright Getty Images
Image caption Bill Clinton doubled over with laughter in a press conference when Boris Yeltsin called the US media "a disaster"

US-Russia relations steadily worsened under the leadership of Vladimir Putin, a former Russian intelligence official who became president in 2000. George W Bush, who became US president a year later, attempted to bring Mr Putin on side but the pair's relationship slowly soured over the eight years Mr Bush was in office.

"I think Putin is not a democrat anymore," he told the visiting prime minister of Slovenia in 2006. "He's a tsar. I think we've lost him."

When Barack Obama became US president in 2009, he tried a new strategy of going around Mr Putin. The Russian leader had stepped aside to comply with Russia's two-term presidential limit, and installed Dmitry Medvedev in his place.

President Obama attempted to develop a relationship with Mr Medvedev, and in 2009 dispatched his Secretary of State Hillary Clinton to meet her Russian counterpart Sergei Lavrov with the goal of re-setting US-Russia relations. She even went armed with a toy button labelled "reset" in English and Russian, only for it to be revealed that the Russian word they'd used in fact meant "overload".

US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton (L) smiles with Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov after she gave him a device with red knob during a meeting on March 6, 2009 in Geneva. Image copyright Getty Images
Image caption Don't forget the reset button
The hands of US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton and Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov rest on a red button marked 'reset' in English and 'overload' in Russian Image copyright Getty Images
Image caption The reset was about as effective as the toy button

Russia later pointedly refused US demands for them to extradite the whistleblower Edward Snowden. Mr Obama cancelled a trip to Moscow and distanced himself from Mr Putin.

Then in 2014 Russia annexed Crimea, breaking for the first time the Helsinki Accord signed by Ford and Brezhnev in 1975 and heaping international opprobrium and sanctions on itself. President Obama criticised Mr Putin, but made it clear he had no intention of entering into any kind of conflict.

"This is not another cold war that we're entering into," he said. "Now is not the time for bluster … There are no easy answers, no military solution."

Presidents Trump and Putin in Helsinki, 16 June Image copyright Reuters
Image caption The two leaders met with only translators as witnesses

Now Donald Trump is president and the US is once again seeking a kind of reset. Mr Trump went into the 16 July summit with Mr Putin with US-Russia relations under a heavy raincloud at home.

US intelligence agencies have unanimously concluded that Russia conducted a cyber operation to influence the outcome of the US presidential election in 2016, and a special counsel investigation led by a former director of the FBI is investigating whether Mr Trump's campaign team colluded in that effort.

In a press conference, President Trump defended Russia over the claims, contradicting US intelligences, saying Russia had no reason to meddle.

Mr Trump also blamed poor relations with Russia on past US administrations rather than Russian actions.

The US president has since faced a barrage of criticism from both sides of the US political divide for his defence of Russia.

In the end, Mr Putin said the ball was in Mr Trump's court, and gifted the US president a World Cup football.

President Vladimir Putin hands President Donald Trump a World Cup football during a joint press conference after their summit on July 16, 2018 in Helsinki, Finland Image copyright Getty Images
Image caption President Trump said he would give the football to his 12-year-old son, Barron

.

More on this story