US & Canada

US disease labs 'made dangerous pathogen transport errors'

Media playback is unsupported on your device
Media captionCDC Director Thomas Frieden "we need to look at our culture of safety throughout all of our laboratories".

US government infectious disease labs mishandled dangerous pathogens five times in the last decade, according to a health agency report.

This year alone, workers mishandled samples of anthrax and the highly-infectious H5N1 avian flu.

In response, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) has closed the two labs involved.

The agency has also temporarily barred high-security labs from transporting dangerous pathogens.

There have been no reported infections from previous cases, and no-one potentially exposed to anthrax has shown signs of illness, CDC officials said.


"These events should never have happened," CDC Director Tom Frieden told reporters on Friday.

"I'm disappointed, and frankly I'm angry about it," he said, adding later he was "astonished that this could have happened here".

The incidents were listed in a report on a potential anthrax exposure in June, which occurred when researchers in a high-level biosecurity laboratory failed to follow proper procedures and did not deactivate the bacteria.

The samples were then moved to a lower-security lab in the agency's Atlanta campus.

"This is not the first time an event of this nature has occurred at CDC, nor the first time it occurred from the [bioterror response] laboratory," the report said.

Image copyright AFP
Image caption The anthrax bacterium, shown in a 2001 US defence department photo, can cause death if untreated

The CDC only recently learned of a separate incident in May in which a sample of the avian flu was cross-contaminated with a highly pathogenic version of the virus and then shipped to an agriculture department laboratory.

The influenza lab and the bioterror response laboratory have been temporarily closed in response.

The other incidents reported by the CDC:

  • In 2006, the CDC's bioterror lab transferred anthrax DNA to outside labs, believing the sample had been deactivated
  • Also in 2006, samples from a different CDC lab were found to contain live botulism bacteria
  • Researchers sent an infectious strain of the bacterium Brucella to outside laboratories as early as 2001 because they mistook it for a vaccine version; newly available test methods in 2009 confirmed it was not.

The revelations come just days after US officials announced long forgotten vials of smallpox left in a cardboard box had been discovered by a government scientist at a research centre near Washington.

The virus was located in six freeze-dried and sealed vials, according to the CDC.

On Friday, the CDC announced that at least two of the vials contained the live virus but that no infections had been reported as a result of the incident.

It is believed to be the first time unaccounted-for smallpox was been discovered in the US. The disease was officially declared eradicated in the 1980s.

More on this story

Related Internet links

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites