BBC Sport pundits Martin McHugh, Oisin McConville and Owen Mulligan fancy Tyrone to win Saturday's Ulster SFC replay and debate whether Benny Coulter should start for Down at Newry.
"Benny Coulter may start for Down. Conor Gormley will start for Tyrone," said former Tyrone star Mulligan.
"Benny Coulter should not start," insisted McHugh."At this stage, he is more effective being used from the bench. I don't think he has the legs for the full 70 minutes."
However, McConville believed Down should gamble on using veteran Coulter from the start and see how long he can last.