St Paul's equalised in the final minute to grab a 3-3 draw against Rozel Rovers and narrowly avoid a third successive defeat.
Both sides went into the game without a point in the Jersey Premiership this season, with two losses from two.
Ryan Le Cornu hit a hat-trick for Rovers but goals from Harrison Jukes, Jack Cannon and Mark Lucas secured a point for Saints.
In the other top flight game Grouville left it late to beat Trinity 2-1.
Russell Le Feuvre gave Grouville an early lead but Peter Grierson hit back for Trinity on 12 minutes.
Joel Speight stabbed home the late winner.