Cuthbert Ottaway: England's sporting genius rediscovered

By William KremerBBC World Service
Cuthbert Ottaway and his new memorial, covered with an Eton flag

England's first football captain was arguably the greatest sportsman of his - or perhaps any - era.

Cuthbert Ottaway lifted the FA Cup as skipper of Oxford University, represented them at five different sports ranging from athletics to real tennis, and once shared a 150-run partnership with WG Grace in the highest level of cricket.

His most notable achievement was captaining England in the first ever international football match though. About 4,000 spectators, including a "large number of ladies", gathered to watch the historic game against Scotland at the West of Scotland Cricket Club in Partick on 30 November 1872.

It was reported to have been an exciting match yet, like many an international friendly since, ended in a 0-0 draw.

So Ottaway - who was also a barrister and died at the age of only 28 after "catching a chill on a night out dancing" - had quite a sporting CV.

Yet when Michael Southwick, a handyman from Winlaton, near Newcastle, decided to find out more about this character with the olde-worlde name, he drew a blank.

Even Ottaway's place of burial was unknown. When Southwick finally traced it to Paddington Old Cemetery,external-link he found a faceless stone slab, as the granite memorial it had once supported had been removed by Westminster Council in the 1970s.

So he set out on a three-year mission to write Ottaway's biography,external-link discovering a man of breath-taking sporting ability and versatility.

Ottaway first established himself as a sportsman at Eton,external-link after winning a scholarship to the famous school. He won championships in racketsexternal-link - a predecessor to squash - and played the Eton field game,external-link their version of football.

But it was in the national sport of the day, cricket, that he truly excelled. As a 16-year-old, he played for Eton against Marylebone Cricket Club (MCC), scoring 55 runs, and then went on to clock up nine centuries in a single season in 1869.

Oxford's only FA Cup-winning sid
Oxford University's only FA Cup-winning side - Ottaway is sitting on the far left

Later that year, he won a place at Brasenose College, Oxford,external-link and went on to represent the University at the top level in five different sports - athletics, rackets, real tennis, cricket and football - which remains a record.

Ottaway's sporting genius reached its zenith in 1872. Following his 150-run partnership with Grace,external-link the sporting superstar of the day, in a Gentlemen v Players matchexternal-link - the highest level of cricket at the time - he was invited to take part in a "Gentlemen of England" tour of North America. Effectively, it was an invitation to play for the national cricket team.

They played eight undefeated matches - five in Canada and three in the United States - with Ottaway opening the batting with Grace as well as keeping wicket. In the first match, against Montreal, he made nine stumpings and shared in a 100-run opening partnership.

During this time, football was emerging as a means for old-boys from different public schools to play ball games against each other.

A ticket to the 1872 football match
An original ticket to the famous match

And in November, Ottaway, fresh from his cricket tour of North America, was appointed as England's captain for the first ever international football match, against Scotland. It's fair to say his side's style of play was primitive.

"England would run with the ball in a rolling maul, like in rugby, but with the ball at the feet rather than in the hand," says Southwick. A player dribbling would be protected by his team-mates barging opponents out the of way.

In contrast, their Scottish opponents ran forward in pairs, passing the ball between themselves. It was called the "combination game", an early version of modern football.

Anarchic and amateurish as the early game might seem now, Ottaway was undoubtedly an effective forward.

"He was a flair player," says Southwick. "He was very fast - after all he was a sprinter and long jumper - and also agile. Pace would have been an important part of his game."

Exciting and historic the match may have been, yet it still ended goalless.

In March 1873, Ottaway played for Oxford University in only the second final of the Football Association Challenge Cup - the world's oldest football competition, which became known as the FA Cup - against Wanderers at Lillie Bridgeexternal-link in London. His side lost 2-0 though.

A year later he made amends, captaining Oxford to a 2-0 win over the Royal Engineers at the Kennington Oval thanks to goals from Charles Mackarness and Frederick Patton.

Shortly afterwards, Ottaway captained Oxford University in their first varsity football match against Cambridge University, a match which must have been a bizarre spectacle.

All 11 Cambridge players stood on their own goal line for almost the entire game. Ottaway instructed his men to hang back and tempt the enemy out and eventually they scored to win 1-0.

In 1875, he played in his third consecutive FA Cup final, this time for Old Etonians against the Royal Engineers. The game, again held at the Kennington Oval, was played in a howling gale and ended 1-1. It led to the convention of the teams swapping ends at half-time, to equalise the effect of the wind. Previously, teams had changed ends only when a goal was scored or if a half ended goalless.

This became Ottaway's last-known football match, as in the 37th minute he received a "severe hack" to his ankle and was forced to leave the field and miss the replay, which the Royal Engineers won 2-0.

Ottaway subsequently married and began to focus on his burgeoning career as a barrister. Then, on 2 April 1878, at the age of just 28, he died, from pneumonia caught on a night out dancing.

In the ensuing years, Ottaway seems to have been gradually forgotten. Until now that is.

Southwick's biography of him was published in 2009 and read by Paul McKay, a player for the England Fans' Football Club, who was "horrified" by the dilapidated state of Ottaway's grave when he visited it.

He promptly set about raising funds for a new memorial and it was unveiled in a ceremony last week, while two commemorative football matches took place at one of Ottaway's former clubs, Marlow FC.

Cuthbert Ottaway's grave in 2006 and Paul McKay and Mick Southwick standing next to the new memorial
Cuthbert Ottaway's grave in 2006 and Paul McKay and Mick Southwick standing next to the new memorial

The day before the recent friendly against Scotland at Wembley, England captain Steven Gerrard admitted he had only recently heard of Ottaway.

"He had the honour of being the first England captain and it is great that what he achieved is being recognised in this way," the Liverpool player said of the new memorial.

But for McKay, whose day job is as a senior manager at Nottinghamshire County Council, the battle to revive Ottaway's name is not over. He is now lobbying the FA to name a hospitality suite after him at St George's Park, the national football centre.

"Bobby Moore's grave would never have been allowed to go into that state of disrepair," McKay says. "It is very difficult to compare the great Sir Bobby Moore with Cuthbert Ottaway, but he was England's first football captain. Bobby Moore followed in his footsteps."

The first England captain and the latest one

Cuthbert OttawaySteven Gerrard
OccupationStudent, barristerFootballer
EducationEton then Brasenose College, OxfordLiverpool Academy
Age when England captain2130
Number of England caps2103
Played soccer for...Oxford University, Marlow FC, Crystal Palace FC, Old Etonians, EnglandLiverpool FC, England
Footballing salary£0£7.2m (2012)
NicknameOjibbaway (The Ojibwa are an Indian tribe in Ontario, where Ottaway had top score in a cricket game)Stevie G
They said..."His beautiful footballing science exhibited how a ball ought to be taken through a host of foes" (match report)"A Boy's Own hero, an arresting presence, even, at times, a force of nature on the football field" (Daily Telegraphexternal-link)

Michael Southwick and Paul McKay were interviewed on World Football on the BBC World Service. Listen to the programme on iPlayer or get the World Football podcast.


Join the conversation

These comments are now closed.


Top Stories