Scottish Championship
Dundee UtdDundee United1DundeeDundee1

Dundee United 1-1 Dundee: Hosts stretch lead at top despite being held

By Richard WintonBBC Sport Scotland at Tannadice
Graham Dorrans (right) scores Dundee's equaliser
Graham Dorrans (right) levelled for Dundee after Nicky Clark's opener for the home side

Dundee United moved 14 points clear at the summit of the Scottish Championship despite being denied a 10th consecutive win by city rivals Dundee.

United, who had won the first two derbies of the season, seized control thanks to Nicky Clark's fifth-minute finish and looked like continuing their 100% home league record.

However, Graham Dorrans' composed second-half intervention earned Dundee the draw which ensures they edge up to third place and stay within 17 points of their neighbours.

Has the title race been run?

When does a race become a procession? The weight of numbers in United's favour now is getting close to necessitating that revision, even if this was their first stutter since a chastening hiding at Queen of the South in mid-October.

Since then, Robbie Neilson's side have played 10, won nine, scored 21 and conceded just three. Their nearest challengers are 14 adrift; their city rivals a further three back. A tally of 71 points has won the title in two of the past three seasons and United are just 25 points shy of that mark with 17 games still to play. The rest could be forgiven for thinking the baw is burst.

This was not one of the league leaders' more fluent performances in front of just over 14,000 fans, but it was only the fourth Championship game they have failed to win this term, and the first they have drawn.

Clark's goal, which finally punctuated a frantic opening five minutes, was ruthlessly accomplished. Youngsters Louis Appere and Jamie Robson combined down the left before the latter fizzed a vicious low ball across the area. Clark, a beat ahead of a blue shirted cadre, darted towards it and used the pace on the delivery to deceive startled goalkeeper Jack Hamilton with a cute flicked finish.

Neilson had spoken of the importance of December and of ending the year with 10 victories in a row, but that milestone was to prove elusive in this combustible contest. Dundee, stung by the memories of two defeats against United this term - 6-2 here and 2-0 at Dens - combined finesse with ferocity.

The narrow shape deployed by James McPake caused issues when United attacked, but it also gave the visitors a degree of authority in midfield. Dorrans and Finlay Robertson showed no deficit of composure, with the 17-year-old gilding a mature display with one particular moment of class - a sumptuous chipped pass behind the United defence that deserved better than a heavy Paul McGowan touch that allowed Benjamin Siegrist to smother.

Dorrans, too, would scrawl his signature on the encounter with the goal that hauled Dundee level. McPake had spoken pre-match about there being little between the sides in terms of quality and the former Scotland international franked that claim with a smart touch and strike after United failed to properly clear a ball into their box.

The concession rattled United temporarily, the hosts perhaps dwelling on presentable chances spurned by Lawrence Shankland and Ian Harkes before the break. Another moment of hesitation in defence should really have allowed Dundee to nick a second - Danny Johnson narrowly failing to connect with Sean Mackie's enticing centre - but United would rediscover their authority.

A back-post Shankland header rippled the side-netting and another tame shot from the division's top scorer was fielded easily, but cleaving further opportunities proved beyond them. Whether capitalising on this minor stutter is too much for United's pursuers remains to be seen.

Lawrence Shankland after missing a chance for Dundee United

'A proper Premiership derby match' - post-match reaction

Dundee United head coach Robbie Neilson: "We've played a lot better this season, but at the end of the day it's another point on the board, another step towards getting the title.

"We got caught up in the derby atmosphere of 'You kick it, we kick it'. A draw is probably a fair result.

"Dundee are a good team, they should be up at the top of the table with us. In my opinion it was a proper Premiership derby match."

Dundee manager James McPake: "In terms of derby performances this season we were better. We showed up for a start. But the disappointing thing is we should have won the game.

"In the second half we were far superior. A lot of our play deserved better.

"Graham Dorrans is far too good for this league. I hope he's here for as long as I'm here. He raises the tempo, he dictated the pace of play in the second half - I thought he was outstanding."


Dundee Utd

Formation 4-4-2

  • 1Siegrist
  • 2Smith
  • 44Watson
  • 6Reynolds
  • 17Robson
  • 7McMullan
  • 23Harkes
  • 18ButcherBooked at 90mins
  • 27Appere
  • 24Shankland
  • 10ClarkSubstituted forSporleat 77'minutes


  • 3Sporle
  • 5Connolly
  • 11Smith
  • 13Mehmet
  • 20Chalmers
  • 25King
  • 40Mochrie


Formation 4-1-2-1-2

  • 1Hamilton
  • 2Kerr
  • 3McGheeBooked at 31mins
  • 6Meekings
  • 23Marshall
  • 14DorransBooked at 68mins
  • 10McGowan
  • 21MackieBooked at 20mins
  • 19Robertson
  • 18JohnsonSubstituted forNelsonat 62'minutesBooked at 80mins
  • 28Hemmings


  • 5Forster
  • 7Todd
  • 8Byrne
  • 9Nelson
  • 12Ferrie
  • 22Moore
  • 26Mulligan
Alan Muir

Match Stats

Home TeamDundee UtdAway TeamDundee
Shots on Target

Live Text

  1. Post update

    Match ends, Dundee United 1, Dundee 1.

  2. Full Time

    Second Half ends, Dundee United 1, Dundee 1.

  3. Booking

    Calum Butcher (Dundee United) is shown the yellow card.

  4. Post update

    Foul by Adrián Sporle (Dundee United).

  5. Post update

    Finlay Robertson (Dundee) wins a free kick in the attacking half.

  6. Post update

    Corner, Dundee. Conceded by Paul Watson.

  7. Post update

    Attempt saved. Lawrence Shankland (Dundee United) left footed shot from the centre of the box is saved in the centre of the goal.

  8. Post update

    Corner, Dundee United. Conceded by Jordan Marshall.

  9. Post update

    Attempt saved. Andrew Nelson (Dundee) header from the centre of the box is saved in the centre of the goal.

  10. Post update

    Calum Butcher (Dundee United) wins a free kick in the attacking half.

  11. Post update

    Foul by Andrew Nelson (Dundee).

  12. Post update

    Attempt blocked. Paul McMullan (Dundee United) right footed shot from the centre of the box is blocked.

  13. Booking

    Andrew Nelson (Dundee) is shown the yellow card.

  14. Post update

    Foul by Mark Reynolds (Dundee United).

  15. Post update

    Sean Mackie (Dundee) wins a free kick in the attacking half.

  16. Post update

    Ian Harkes (Dundee United) wins a free kick in the attacking half.

  17. Post update

    Foul by Andrew Nelson (Dundee).

  18. Substitution

    Substitution, Dundee United. Adrián Sporle replaces Nicky Clark.

  19. Post update

    Foul by Jamie Robson (Dundee United).

  20. Post update

    Finlay Robertson (Dundee) wins a free kick in the defensive half.

As It Stood

1Dundee Utd19151343152846
2Inverness CT1810262721632
6Queen of Sth176471819-122
9Partick Thistle1853102434-1018
View full Scottish Championship table

Top Stories

Around Scottish sport