The FA Cup - Third Round - Replay
TranmereTranmere Rovers2WatfordWatford1

Tranmere shock Watford in FA Cup to set up Man Utd fourth-round tie

By Phil DawkesBBC Sport

League One Tranmere shocked Premier League Watford in an FA Cup third-round replay to set up a tie against 12-time winners Manchester United.

In a game rescheduled from earlier in the month because of a waterlogged pitch, Rovers capitalised on a hugely under-strength Hornets and best navigated a dire, sand-covered Prenton Park surface to finally settle the tie in extra time.

Substitute striker Paul Mullin, who came off the bench to score a late penalty at Vicarage Road and complete a remarkable Rovers comeback from 3-0 down to set up this replay, went one better with a headed winner 14 minutes into the extra 30.

The Hornets had come back themselves in normal time, with Kaylen Hinds firing in through a mass of players to level after Manny Monthe had given the home side the lead.

The silver lining for Nigel Pearson's side is that they will not have to play what would have been a fourth game in nine days in the fourth round on Sunday, and will instead be able to focus all their efforts on avoiding relegation from the top flight.

Tranmere, though, get to do this all over again at the weekend, hosting Manchester United with an even greater shock in mind and on a pitch unlike any other the Red Devils will have played on this campaign.

Rovers dig deep again

This FA Cup run has been something to savour in what has been an otherwise tough season back in League One for Tranmere.

The club have been on an upward trajectory over the past two campaigns, returning to the Football League in 2018-19 after three seasons in the National League and then following that up with a second successive promotion to the third tier.

But they have won just five of 25 league games since then and sit 21st in the League One table.

However, both the original tie and this replay have showcased the battling spirit that Micky Mellon has instilled in his players. And on a sandy, rapidly deteriorating surface such as this, that appetite for battle was key.

They won tackles, stuck a boot in where their opponents would not and remained alive to the opportunities that chaos can create in a minefield of a penalty area.

Blackett-Taylor and 37-year-old veteran midfielder Neil Danns both went close before defender Monthe - also a scorer in the original tie - struck his opener in the first half, and they did not wilt when Watford levelled in the second.

They could easily have won the tie in normal time, but Mullin hit the outside of the post from a tight angle and Danns fired just past the far post with seconds left.

They were not to be denied, though, as Mullin timed his run to perfection to meet a flicked on cross from Liam Ridehalgh and head his side into the fourth round and the chance to show what they have got against a struggling Manchester United.

"I don't think it's an opportunity because of the form United are in. I know they have a threat. We have to make sure we are ready," said Mellon.

"We will give it everything we have got. There is no doubt we will be up against a good side.

"We have to go out there and understand that is what will come here. They are an unbelievable football club and we are a League One club, at the bottom end of League One, but we are going to give it everything we've got.

"We will try to represent the club again and the players will run their socks off again and who knows?"

An unenviable task for Man Utd

Ole Gunnar Solskjaer's side will not relish the prospect of facing Tranmere on this pitch.

The FA Cup represents one of United's main potential avenues to silverware this season and you would therefore expect Solskjaer to field a stronger XI than Watford did for this game.

But they will face the same, alien problems of inconsistent bounce and roll on a surface that is as much sand as grass.

Plus, they come into the tie at arguably the lowest moment of Solskjaer's time at the club, having meekly lost their last two games - at fierce rivals Liverpool and then at home against Burnley.

Clearly, Solskjaer has the superior players at his disposal but Tranmere will have the bit between their teeth and a leveller beneath their feet.

Second-string Hornets stung

Kaylen Hinds scores for Watford
Kaylen Hinds joined Watford in August 2019 following a spell in Germany with Wolfsburg

Precariously placed in the Premier League and having just lost at relegation rivals Villa, this was a game Watford could have done without, and one they should have avoided in the first place.

Leading 3-0 at half-time in the original fixture at Vicarage Road, their place in round four was essentially booked, before their second-half capitulation allowed Tranmere parity and a replay.

When the elements then intervened and the game on 14 January was postponed, it left the Hornets facing a horror run of fixtures at a crucial juncture in their season.

No wonder then that Pearson opted to make so many changes from the defeat at Villa, with Christian Kabasele, Jose Holebas and Andre Gray the most recognisable first-team figures in a team largely comprised of under-23 players.

As an indication of how deeply the Watford boss dug into his squad, the average shirt number for the 18 named in the match-day squad was 38, with the highest on display the 72 sported by unused substitute Andi Janjeva.

None of them particularly covered themselves in glory, never fully getting to grips with their opponents or environment.

Teenage Brazilian forward Joao Pedro showed the briefest of flashes and drew a good save out of home keeper Scott Davies, who was also called into action to superbly palm away a curling Callum Whelan shot in extra time, while Holebas hit the post with an angled drive.

But these were rare moments of attacking flair in an encounter that will be quickly forgotten if the returning first team can return to winning ways in the league in nine days' time.

"It was a tough game," said Pearson. "We learned a lot about our young players tonight and I thought the senior players were excellent.

"Congratulations to Tranmere. For people who possibly thought we weren't too interested in it, we were but we couldn't risk too many first-team players."

Pearson also dismissed any notion that the pitch was to blame for the loss, adding; "It is the same for everyone. They showed a lot of energy and desire. In the first half we were second-best in terms of desire."

Man of the match - Manny Monthe (Tranmere)

Emmanuel Monthe fires in for Tranmere against Watford
Monthe scored the opener and then stood tall to help keep Watford at bay with four clearances

What's next?

Tranmere welcome Manchester United to Prenton Park for the fourth-round tie, kicking off at 15:00 GMT on Sunday. Watford get a short break from action to lick their wounds before hosting Everton in the Premier League on Saturday, 1 February.

Line-ups

Tranmere

Formation 4-2-3-1

  • 1Davies
  • 14Caprice
  • 24Clarke
  • 6Monthe
  • 3Ridehalgh
  • 35DannsSubstituted forGilmourat 100'minutes
  • 17Perkins
  • 7Morris
  • 11JenningsBooked at 55mins
  • 23Blackett-TaylorSubstituted forWoodsat 109'minutes
  • 10FerrierSubstituted forMullinat 64'minutesSubstituted forPayneat 117'minutes

Substitutes

  • 2Woods
  • 4Nelson
  • 9Mullin
  • 18Hepburn-Murphy
  • 20Gilmour
  • 25Pilling
  • 45Payne

Watford

Formation 4-4-2

  • 35Bachmann
  • 41Barrett
  • 27Kabasele
  • 51Spencer-Adams
  • 25Holebas
  • 42Whelan
  • 20QuinaSubstituted forWiseat 105'minutes
  • 24Dele-BashiruSubstituted forHindsat 45'minutes
  • 44HungboSubstituted forBennettsat 99'minutes
  • 17João PedroSubstituted forDalbyat 81'minutes
  • 18Gray

Substitutes

  • 30Dahlberg
  • 40Dalby
  • 45Balogun
  • 46Wise
  • 53Hinds
  • 58Bennetts
  • 72Janjeva
Referee:
Tony Harrington
Attendance:
10,039

Match Stats

Home TeamTranmereAway TeamWatford
Possession
Home59%
Away41%
Shots
Home20
Away11
Shots on Target
Home3
Away3
Corners
Home7
Away4
Fouls
Home8
Away21

Live Text

  1. Post update

    Match ends, Tranmere Rovers 2, Watford 1.

  2. Post update

    Second Half Extra Time ends, Tranmere Rovers 2, Watford 1.

  3. Post update

    Corner, Tranmere Rovers. Conceded by Callum Whelan.

  4. Post update

    Stefan Payne (Tranmere Rovers) wins a free kick on the right wing.

  5. Post update

    Foul by Mason Barrett (Watford).

  6. Post update

    Foul by Liam Ridehalgh (Tranmere Rovers).

  7. Post update

    Callum Whelan (Watford) wins a free kick on the right wing.

  8. Substitution

    Substitution, Tranmere Rovers. Stefan Payne replaces Paul Mullin.

  9. Post update

    Paul Mullin (Tranmere Rovers) wins a free kick in the defensive half.

  10. Post update

    Foul by Jayden Bennetts (Watford).

  11. Substitution

    Substitution, Tranmere Rovers. Calum Woods replaces Corey Taylor.

  12. Post update

    Paul Mullin (Tranmere Rovers) wins a free kick on the right wing.

  13. Post update

    Foul by José Holebas (Watford).

  14. Post update

    Attempt blocked. Callum Whelan (Watford) right footed shot from outside the box is blocked.

  15. Post update

    Second Half Extra Time begins Tranmere Rovers 2, Watford 1.

  16. Substitution

    Substitution, Watford. Henry Wise replaces Domingos Quina.

  17. Post update

    First Half Extra Time ends, Tranmere Rovers 2, Watford 1.

  18. Post update

    Attempt missed. Kieron Morris (Tranmere Rovers) right footed shot from outside the box is close, but misses to the right following a corner.

  19. Post update

    Corner, Tranmere Rovers. Conceded by Christian Kabasele.

  20. Goal!

    Goal! Tranmere Rovers 2, Watford 1. Paul Mullin (Tranmere Rovers) header from very close range to the bottom right corner. Assisted by Corey Taylor.

Comments

Join the conversation

These comments are now closed.

314 comments

Top Stories

The FA Cup