Got a TV Licence?

You need one to watch live TV on any channel or device, and BBC programmes on iPlayer. It’s the law.

Find out more
I don’t have a TV Licence.

Summary

  1. Hart mistake leads to equaliser
  2. Hart sent wrong way by Atalanta penalty

Live Reporting

By Neil Johnston

All times stated are UK

Get involved

Goodbye

First he was rejected by Pep Guardiola, then named "John" on the team sheet, and now a mistake on his debut...it hasn't been a great few days for Joe Hart.

There's still plenty of time for him to show why he is England's number one.

Thanks for your company. Until next time...

Get Involved

#bbceurofooty

Michael Roughton: I'm sure Hart will be praised if he 'fronts up' for his latest mistake. Not making it in the first place would be better...  

Atalanta 2-1 Torino

A Madness tune blasts out of the speakers as the players make their way off the pitch. Joe Hart is one of the last to leave. He puffs out his cheeks as he joins his team-mates in applauding Torino's travelling support. It's not been the best of starts for the England keeper.

FULL-TIME

Atalanta 2-1 Torino

A debut to forget.

Atalanta 2-1 Torino

Wonder what Sam Allardyce is thinking? His number one keeper has not covered himself in glory and there is another England match coming up next month. Torino's next match is against Empoli on 18 September.

Atalanta 2-1 Torino

Five minutes of additional time. Atalanta, without a point before today, are closing in on a comeback win.

Atalanta 2-1 Torino

More dramarama as Atalanta's boss Gian Piero Gasperini is sent to the stands for arguing with the officials. That means both coaches have been 'sent off'. 

Atalanta 2-1 Torino

Fair to say this is not a debut Joe Hart will want to remember. 

Joe Hart
Getty Images

GOAL - ATALANTA 2-1 TORINO

Franck Kessie

Joe Hart is playing mind games with Franck Kessie as he walks behind his goal in an effort to make the Atalanta player wait to take the penalty. Kessie finally steps up...and sends Hart the wrong way,

Kessie celebrates
Getty Images

PENALTY TO ATALANTA

Atalanta 1-1 Torino

All eyes on Joe Hart as the referee points to the penalty spot after Lorenzo de Silvestri brings down an Atalanta player. Can Hart redeem himself?

Get Involved

#bbceurofooty

Rizpey: First rejected by Pep, then named "John" on the Atalanta team sheet and now makes that howler. Really feel for Hart. 

Simon Goodall: Joe Hart will be back at Man City. Pep is not afraid to say he's made a mistake. 

CLOSE!

Atalanta 1-1 Torino

Argentine striker Lucas Boye forces a fine full stretch save from Marco Sportiello as Torino move up a gear in the closing stages. 

Atalanta 1-1 Torino

Around 15 minutes to go. Hart has the ball at his feet outside his area. Another long hoof forward in an attempt to spark another attack. Torino are looking the more likely to score a winner.

Get Involved

#bbceurofooty

Where next when Joe Hart's loan ends at Torino?

Boniface nwibo: Liverpool next season. I'm very sure of that.   

G S Webster: Southend Utd need a new goalkeeper. Been shocking since the mighty Bentley moved on.

John McEnerney: Stay where you are Joe Hart because as long as Pep is at MCFC you are not welcome! Ex-pat for the next few years is the best thing.

CLOSE!

Atalanta 1-1 Torino

Former Roma midfielder Marco D'Alessandro is clean through with only Joe Hart to beat. He pulls the trigger...and it's high and wide.

Get Involved

#bbceurofooty

Jay: That's one way to show that you have better feet than hands as a goalkeeper. Not sure that'll convince Pep though.

Alex Shcnopple: Can't criticise Joe there, he's not played enough minutes for some time, so he just needs to adjust & away from City is the right choice.

Atalanta 1-1 Torino

So, no clean sheet for Hart on his Torino debut. I'm afraid he only has himself to blame for that. There's still plenty of time left and Atalanta have their tails up. How will Hart respond?

Atalanta 1-1 Torino

That mistake will haunt Joe Hart. He flapped at that corner when it needed a clean catch. I wonder what Pep Guardiola's thinking...

GOAL - Atalanta 1-1 Torino

Andrea Masiello

Disaster for Joe Hart. Torino's travelling fans are still celebrating when Atalanta win a corner. It's whipped in and Hart comes off his line to collect - only he doesn't. He palms the ball into the path of Andrea Masiello who rifles home. What a mess by England's keeper.

Masiello celebrates
EPA

GOAL - Atalanta 0-1 Torino

Iago Falque

Torino take the lead with a superb free-kick, former Tottenham winger Iago Falque bending the ball over the wall and into the top corner. Joe Hart reacts by punching the air.