Six Nations 2015: France 15-8 Scotland

By Andy BurkeBBC Scotland
2015 Six Nations: France 15-8 Scotland highlights
France (9) 15
Pens: Lopez 5
Scotland (8) 8
Try: Fife Pen: Laidlaw

Five penalties from fly-half Camille Lopez consigned Scotland to defeat in their opening Six Nations match for the ninth consecutive year.

The Scots pushed France all the way, but the concession of too many penalties proved to be their undoing.

Dougie Fife crossed for the game's only try, finishing off a fine passage of play to put the Scots within a point.

The French reclaimed the initiative in the second half, and Lopez's accuracy with the boot saw them home.

The Scots arrived at Stade de France in buoyant mood. Reinvigorated since the arrival of Vern Cotter as head coach last summer, they had displayed real signs of progress in the autumn with wins over Argentina and Tonga, and a narrow loss to world champions New Zealand.

The French had plenty of motivation to perform too. In the first international since the recent terrorist attacks in Paris, the national anthem was belted out with added gusto, and the home fans had just two minutes to wait before fly-half Lopez kicked their side into a three-point lead.

Scotland captain Greig Laidlaw and Lopez then traded penalties in an opening period of furious intensity and ferocious defending.

Dougie Fife scored the only try of the match just before half-time
Fife scored the only try of the match just before half-time

After weathering the expected early French storm, the visitors exerted some pressure of their own, with Finn Russell, Alex Dunbar and Stuart Hogg all finding gaps in the home defence, but some stellar defending close to the try-line kept the Scots at bay.

Lopez added a third penalty to stretch France's lead to 9-3, but Scotland hit back with the game's only try right on half-time, and it was a superbly crafted score.

Another break from Hogg put the Scots on the front foot deep in opposition territory, and after several attempts at the French line, the ball was spun wide to Mark Bennett who slipped a tackle and found Euan Murray, with the prop displaying the velvet hands of a fly-half to slip Fife in at the corner.

Laidlaw's missed touchline conversion meant France led 9-8 at the break, and Lopez made it four from four with the boot early in the second half to take the sting out of the Scots' revival.

France stepped up their game after the break, pinning the Scots back in their own half with some powerful running.

As they came under more pressure from the French, the visitors began to fall foul of referee Nigel Owens, and the loss of Johnnie Beattie to the sin bin did not help their cause.

Yoann Huget looked for all the world like he was about to put the Scots to the sword as he raced for the line after a failed interception attempt from Tim Visser, but an outstanding last-ditch tackle from Bennett forced Huget to fumble the ball over the line.

The game became loose in the closing stages, with the Scots desperately trying to fashion the score they needed, and the French looking to breach the visitors try-line for the first time.

The best Les Bleus could manage was a fifth penalty from Lopez, but that was enough to seal the win.

The Scots can take encouragement from many aspects of their play, but once again they are left with the bitter aftertaste of Six Nations defeat.

Stuart Hogg (right)
Scotland full-back Stuart Hogg made 92m in the first half in Paris
Teddy Thomas
France have never previously failed to score a try against Scotland in the Six Nations
France celebrate
France have won their last eight Tests against Scotland in the Six Nations

France: Spedding, Huget, Bastareaud, Fofana, Thomas, Lopez, Kockott, Menini, Guirado, Slimani, Pape, Maestri, Le Roux, Dusautoir, Chouly.

Replacements: Lamerat for Bastareaud (71), Parra for Kockott (54), Ben Arous for Menini (41), Kayser for Guirado (47), Atonio for Slimani (54), Taofifenua for Pape (60). Not Used: Goujon, Tales.

Scotland: Hogg, Seymour, Bennett, Dunbar, Visser, Russell, Laidlaw, Dickinson, Ford, Murray, R. Gray, J. Gray, Harley, Cowan, Beattie.

Replacements: Fife for Seymour (16), Horne for Dunbar (67), Hidalgo-Clyne for Laidlaw (78), Reid for Dickinson (64), F. Brown for Ford (67), Cross for Murray (64), Hamilton for R. Gray (64), Strokosch for Harley (52). Sin Bin: Beattie (61).

Att: 80,000

Ref: Nigel Owens (Wales)

Match stats
2 (0)Scrums won (lost)4 (1)
18 (2)Line-outs won (lost)11 (2)
8Pens conceded12
81 (7)Rucks/mauls won (lost)66 (7)
34Possession kicked30
96 (21)Tackles made (missed)122 (18)
406Metres made347
5Line breaks3
Provided by Accenture

Top Stories